Influence of Spinal Needle Tip Design on Post-Dural Puncture Headache Following Spinal Anaesthesia: A Comparative Study

Main Article Content

Anil Shetty, Disney Das, Ranjan Nayak

Abstract

Background: Post-dural puncture headache (PDPH) is a significant complication following spinal anaesthesia, with incidence influenced by needle design, gauge, and patient factors. While atraumatic (pencil-point) needles such as Whitacre are associated with lower PDPH rates compared to cutting needles like Quincke, their adoption remains inconsistent, particularly in resource-limited settings. This study aimed to compare the incidence of PDPH between 25G Quincke-Babcock and 25G Whitacre needles in adult patients undergoing subarachnoid block, and to evaluate procedural characteristics such as ease of puncture and associated factors.


Materials and Methods: A prospective, double-blinded, observational comparative study was conducted over 18 months (May 2024–October 2025) at the Department of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care, Justice K.S. Hegde Charitable Hospital, affiliated with K.S. Hegde Medical Academy, NITTE (Deemed to be University), Mangaluru. A total of 174 adult patients (ASA I–II), aged 18–65 years, undergoing elective surgery under spinal anaesthesia were included. Patients received subarachnoid block using either a 25G Quincke-Babcock or 25G Whitacre needle. Standardized procedural protocols were followed, and both patients and outcome assessors were blinded to needle type. The primary outcome was the incidence of PDPH, assessed using established diagnostic criteria over a 10-day postoperative follow-up period. Secondary outcomes included ease of puncture, number of attempts, and influence of patient positioning. Statistical analysis included descriptive methods and ordinal regression to evaluate predictors of procedural difficulty.


Results: The study population had a median age of 43 years, with a slight male predominance and overall low-risk profile. Notably, no cases of PDPH were observed in either needle group during the follow-up period. Most procedures were successful on the first attempt (67.2%), and puncture was categorized as easy in most cases (67.8%). The sitting position was used more frequently than the lateral position. Ordinal regression analysis demonstrated a non-significant trend toward greater technical difficulty with the Whitacre needle compared to Quincke-Babcock (OR 1.73, p=0.095). Patient positioning (sitting vs lateral) did not significantly influence ease of puncture.


Conclusion: In a relatively healthy, non-obstetric adult population, the use of fine-gauge (25G) spinal needles was associated with an extremely low—effectively absent—incidence of PDPH, regardless of needle design. While atraumatic needles are traditionally favoured for reducing PDPH risk, this study suggests that in low-risk populations with standardized technique, both Quincke and Whitacre needles may yield similarly favorable outcomes. However, Whitacre needles demonstrated a tendency toward increased technical difficulty, highlighting a potential trade-off between procedural ease and theoretical reduction in dural trauma. Larger, multicentric studies including higher-risk populations are required to better define the true comparative benefits and inform standardized clinical guidelines.

Article Details

Section
Articles